top of page
Search

Two and Two: Eat More Plants and Plant More Trees

Jun 18, 2021
3 min read

Updated: Jun 18, 2021

The planet. She ain't going to cool herself. How can we help?


I've been thinking about this a bit and reading up on what various experts are saying and crunching some data from sources like NOAA.gov & OurWorldInData.org. There were two surprising things I learnt in the process. The first was that if we could wave a magic wand and instantly replace all coal and oil burning with some other clean sustainable process, the planet will actually start heating up faster. Let me repeat, the planet's warming trend will accelerate! The second was that in the last 300 years we have de-wilded about a quarter of all habitable land in order to let cattle graze in them. And if we were to simply release these lands back to nature, climate change can pretty much be reversed.


Don't believe me? Here's the data.


Let's look at the effect of fossil fuels on climate. Basically our atmosphere does two things. First, it allows some amount of energy from the sun to reach the land surface of Earth -- let's call this "Allow in". And second, it allows the land surface to radiate back some amount of energy back into space -- let's call this "Allow out". If Allow in is bigger than Allow out, the Earth heats up. If not, she cools down. It turns out that when we burn fossil fuels, two kinds of pollutants are produced: green house gases and aerosols. Green house gases reduce Allow out, and thus having a warming effect. On the other hand, the aerosols reduce Allow in, having a cooling effect. To quantify this: the green house gases produced in 1 year increase heat retention by an additional 0.04 watts per square meter every year (source: NOAA.gov). But the aerosols produced reduce Allow in by 0.95 watts per square meter (source: NOAA.gov). So if we suddenly stopped burning all fossil fuels, our heat retention will jump up from the current 3.18 watts per square meter (source: NOAA.gov) to 4.08 watts per square meter. While we know that pollutants like sulfur dioxide caused aerosols are harmful for many reasons, and we should seek to get rid of them, we also see that from a purely climate perspective we can slow walk that effort.


And let's look at the second item: the impact of de-wilding. Starting from 1700, roughly 2.3 billion hectares of wild land (forests & wild grasslands) were converted to grazing lands for livestock (source: OurWorldInData.org). This is close to 25% of all habitable land. If we were to release these additional grazing lands back to nature, they would start sequestering carbon at a rate of roughly 37 GT CO2e per year (source: WRI.org plus additional calculations). That's a whopping 75% reduction in the total 50 GT CO2e green house gases that are released per year currently (source: OurWorldInData.org)!


So what do these two data points mean for us? It means that we can have a huge impact on climate change by reducing the need for grazing lands and releasing them to nature. And there are, you guessed it, two approaches to solving the problem: top down and bottom up. We will need to use both.

Image showing top down and bottom up solutions.

The bottom up approach is a demand side solution. We as consumers can simply choose to reduce our consumption of animal foods and products -- especially dairy, beef and mutton/lamb which are land intensive -- and increase our consumption of plant rich foods and products. This also comes with two nice side benefits: better health due to reduced risk of many chronic diseases (like cancer, heart disease and diabetes), and the total elimination of world hunger because croplands that were used to produce grain for livestock can now be used for humans.


The top down approach is from the supply side. We have to find ways to "tree-populate" grazing lands by releasing them back to nature. This re-wilding has two side benefits: increasing biodiversity and preventing damage from natural disasters like erosion, floods and fires. The responsible actors here are local, regional and national governments, intergovernmental consortia like the UN, and large philanthropic organizations. Actions range from legislation, regulation, financial incentivisation -- for e.g. carbon credits, land leasing and outright acquisition of land. All of the above actors need encouragement and pressure from us, the broad public, to take action.


The planet. She's always been cool. We too can strive to be with her.







1 Comment


Raju Venkatesan
Raju Venkatesan
Jun 19, 2021

Makes sense. We can still eat fish and chicken if you are craving for meat. Planting trees and reclaiming land will be a lot easier sell to the masses than banning fossil fuel and destroying related economy. Hope this idea gets more steam.

Like

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by JJ Musings. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page