When Mandukya meets Meta
Updated: Oct 29, 2022
Okay, I'll confess - I have a shiny new play toy and was eagerly in pursuit of playgrounds when I ran into Gaudapada's Mandukya Karika. It is the brilliant exposition of the Mandukya Upanishad by Gaudapada, who is considered to be Adi Shankara's guru's guru. What's my play toy? It's a model I call the SimVerse model that I have developed (more on this later). And I was eager to learn what Gaudapada had to say on that topic.
But, before we get ahead of ourselves, some context.
The Upanishads are a preeminent part of the vast Indian Vedic literature. There are more than a hundred Upanishads in all, but about a dozen of them are considered principal Upanishads. Among these the Mandukya Upanishad assumes a unique position. With only twelve verses it is the shortest Upanishad. It is considered the quintessential statement of Vedantic philosophy. And Gaudapada, one of the most brilliant stars in the constellation of Vedantic philosophers, wrote an exposition of the Mandukya Upanishad in the 6th century CE. His work, called the Mandukya Karika, is an exquisitely crafted logical analysis of Mandukya Upanishad, organized in four chapters.
That's enough of a buildup, let's see what Gaudapada actually has to say.
In this blog post, I am going to first explore Gaudapada's work and then see how it does or does not fit the SimVerse model. I'll identify the key claims made in the work. And, equally importantly, I'll point out the empirical observations and inferences that lead to those claims. I will not delve into other aspects of the work, though they are rich and sophisticated.

Let's start with the experiences and observations that Gaudapada analyzes.
We have all experienced the states of waking, dreaming and deep sleep. Now, let's take a closer look at the dreaming state. In a dream, the dreamer perceives stuff, often from a first person perspective. Typically the dreamer experiences a dream world populated with people, things, perhaps other creatures. The dreamer could also perceive internal things like thoughts, feelings and emotions. The dreamer may also have a sense of self that is having these perceptions and acting on those perceptions. All of this feels very real to the dreaming self. The dreaming self never questions the "reality" of the dream world and its objects.
But what happens when the dreamer wakes up? The dream world is gone. The things perceived in the dream are gone. The dreaming self is gone. What remains is the waker. And nothing but the waker. And it is clear to the waker that the dream world was not real. (Note: in the interests of brevity I'll take some liberties with the English language and use the word 'waker' to refer to the person in the awake state).
Now, let's pause and take stock of what happened here.
From the perspective of the dreamer in the dream world:
The dream world is real.
The dream world may have its own concept of time and space, its own rules of engagement -- or lack thereof.
The dreamer has a notion of "self" operating in the dream world -- what the dreamer would refer to using the word "I"
This "I" in the dream world perceives things. The mechanisms of perception could be of many kinds: visual, aural, tactile, etc. This "I" is the subject of those perceptions.
The content of perception could be external to the dreaming self, for e.g. people or things in the dream. It could also be things internal to the dreaming "self" like thoughts, feelings, and emotions. These are the objects of perception.
But, from the perspective of the waker in the waking world:
The dream world including the dreamer was not real -- it was illusory. To elaborate a bit, the dreamer was not real, the people and objects in the dream were not real, events that occurred in the dream world were not real, time and space in the dream world were not real. In short nothing in the dream world was real including the dreamer.
The dream world gained its existence, albeit temporary, from the waker. Simply stated, no waker no dream world.
The waker was an ever present perceiver or subject in the dream world. How do we know that? We know that because on waking up the waker can remember all or part of the dream.
What's more, if you ask the question who or what entity other than the waker was involved in the whole drama, the answer would be: "no other". In the waker's world, the waker is the only entity and hence necessarily a pure subject.
So, we have a situation where something that feels very real at one level may turn out not to be so at another. With this in mind, let's set the dream world aside for a moment and turn our attention to the waker's experience of the waking world.
In the waking world, this is my subjective experience as a waker:
The waking world feels real -- it's solid, vivid.
It has time and space. It has rules of engagement -- for e.g., the laws of Nature. The world abides by these rules and is consistent.
The waker has a notion of "self" operating in the waking world -- what the waker would refer to using the word "I".
The "I" in the waking world perceives things via multiple modes of perception. This "I" is the subject of the perceptions.
The content of perception could be things external to the waker, or things internal like thoughts, feelings and emotions.
Beginning to sound familiar? Clearly, this reads like the experience of the dreamer in the dream world.
Then, the question that naturally arises is: is it possible that our waking experience is not real, much like the dream experience? As the dream world is an appearance to the waker, could the waking world itself be an appearance to an "outer" entity? And to carry the analogy all the way forward, perhaps there is "no other" entity than this "outer" entity?
Clearly this is a possibility. And this is the model proposed by Mandukya Upanishad and its champion Gaudapada. Specifically, he makes two key claims.
The non-reality claim: the world we live in is an appearance to an "outer" entity called Brahman. Thus from the perspective of Brahman, the waking world and its derivatives are not real. The specific technical term for this in Sanskrit is "mithya". Our waking world and its derivatives borrow their existence from Brahman, much like the dream world borrows its existence from the waker.
The non-duality claim: there is "no other": Brahman is without a second, a pure subject. The technical term in Sanskrit for this is "advaita".
In Gaudapada's work the first claim is presented and expounded in Chapter 2 aka Vaitathya Prakarana. The second claim is explained in Chapter 3 aka Advaita Prakarana. Gaudapada does not simply stop after making the claims. He goes on to enumerate over 30 competing models of his day and systematically proceeds to prove them false.
And now, to the second part of my blog post: what do I make of the Mandukya/Gaudapada model?
It's certainly possible that our existence is fully explained by Gaudapada's model. But I also think that there are some new experiences that have become available only very recently that warrant examination. Specifically, I am referring to recent advances in Virtual Reality technology. Currently VR technology is still in its nascent stage. Even so, it is already able to whisk users off to a virtual world and provide them with an immersive experience by merely subverting their visual, aural and some tactile perceptions. You may have seen social media posts about users who got so engrossed in the VR world that they did things like crashing into their television screens in the real world while they thought they were executing a leap in the VR world! When you compare an immersive VR experience with a dream experience, you can see that there are a lot of similarities. To a deeply engrossed player, the VR world feels very real. However, the moment the user unplugs from it, the VR world is gone.
Earlier we had posed the question: is our waking world really the dream world of an "outer" entity. Now with the benefit of having experienced VR technology, we could pose the modified question: is the waking world really the VR world of an "outer" entity? To me, this is a valid question in light of new evidence and experiences that Gaudapada did not have access to.
In my own modest attempt at answering these questions, I propose a slightly different model which I call the SimVerse model. This model makes the following three claims:
The VR game claim: This Universe is a simulation/virtual reality game.
The one gamer claim: There is ONE gamer who is plugged into ALL the characters in the game.
The "no joystick" claim: the gamer is purely an observer, and does not control the game.
This model is further detailed here. It retains the property of mithya or non-reality as expressed in the first claim of Gaudapada. In fact, in the context of the SimVerse model, mithya translates to "virtual". But the model does not strictly adhere to the property of advaita or non-duality as in the second claim of Gaudapada.
Which of these models (if any) is more likely to represent the truth underlying our existence?
That's for you to decide.



Comments