top of page
Search

Maslow on Steroids: the Gravesian Model of Human Development

Jun 11, 2021
4 min read

Image depicting the Maslow pyramid.
Maslow pyramid

Most people are familiar with Maslow's hierarchy of needs. The theory proposes a 5 stage pyramid of needs to explain the progression of human motivation and values. When his contemporary Clare W Graves set about validating the Maslow model, he discovered a more potent evolutionary model of human development. It was also a hierarchical model - a hierarchy of values that govern both individual humans and communities. The levels in this hierarchy evolved over time in response to existential problems of the day. Each new level solved a set of problems found in the previous level, but also introduced the next level of problems.


The Gravesian model provides a framework to understand the motivations and actions of an individual or a group. Thus, it can be used to explain why people and societies behave in a certain way at certain times -- even why, for example, at times it can feel like some people are on an entirely different planet!


The Gravesian evolutionary model is best represented as an ever expanding spiral with many levels, but the first 6 are considered Tier 1. The levels are color coded for ease of reference.

Image depicting the Gravesian spiral
Gravesian spiral

The first level Beige is the base survival level. The focus here is on physical survival, food, shelter and warmth for the individual. The theme is "do what you must to stay alive". Examples are newborn babies, very old people, mentally ill, street people.


The second level Purple is the tribal level. It evolved to provide safety and security by banding together in a community based on kinship. "Keep the ancestral spirits happy and the tribe secure". Sacrifice for the benefit of the tribe. Core values are kinship, safety and tradition. Examples are indigenous tribes, sports fans, college fraternities, cults, gang members, mafia families, Indian "panchayat" system, nepotism.


The next level up Red is the self-assertive level. It evolved to enable individuals to break free from the suffocation of tradition. Break boundaries. Be passionate. Use power and strength to dominate. The world is full of threats. You are either a winner or a loser. Winning justifies everything. Examples are Alexander the Great, Mad Max movies, rock stars, outlaw cowboys, feudal warlords, drug lords.


The fourth level Blue is the absolutist level. It evolved to bring order to the chaos of Red societies. Core values are morality, discipline, authority, order and purpose. What's right and true is what it says in "the book". Consequently, 2 Blue societies based on different "books" may treat each other as enemies. Sacrifice now to receive future rewards. Examples are the Pope, Religion, "a purpose driven life", fundamentalists, Boy Scouts, national governments, nationalism - "my country right or wrong", Westpoint.


The next level Orange is the individualistic/materialistic level. It evolved to break free from the rigid constraints on truth and action imposed by Blue. It doesn't matter what "the book" says, what's true is what you can observe and infer with reason. Express self and achieve success by innovating and strategically manipulating desired outcomes. Examples are Galileo, Adam Smith, Jefferson, Science, materialism, rationalism, constitutional democracies - "we hold these truths to be self-evident", free market capitalism, "greed is good ".


The sixth level Green is the humanistic, egalitarian, communitarian level. It evolved as a reaction to the rampant exploitation of people, species and the planet by Orange in the name of free-market capitalism. Core values are equality, honesty, and connectedness. The goal is "to find happiness by caring for and relating deeply to other beings". Examples are Gandhi, environmental groups, Greenpeace, social activists, veganism.


One thing to note in the spiral is that successive levels alternately shift from focus on the individual to focus on the community and vice-versa. The warm colors (Beige, Red, Orange) represent individual focused levels and the cool colors (Purple, Blue, Green) the community focused ones.


Much as in genetic evolution, each of us has some degree of these "ancestral" value systems at various strengths. One could, for instance, construct "spectral charts" of these colors for each one of us that describe how we go about thinking and behaving in any particular domain of life. In the US, for example, moderate conservatives are likely to be strong in Blue and Orange. Moderate liberals are likely to be strong in Orange and Green. Hard right wingers are likely to be strong in Red, Blue and some Orange. In contrast India has strong Purple and Red in a large swath of the population, with rapidly growing Blue and Orange segments.


Levels beyond the sixth are Tier 2 levels that are projections into the future. People in Tier 2 acknowledge the existence and validity of the Tier 1 levels. They understand that each of these levels is good at solving a certain class of problems. And they are able to communicate with individuals at their respective levels in order to deploy solutions appropriate to the problem. Simply stated, in Tier 2 the solutions must fit the problem, not the other way around. A shining example of this is when Tier 2 thinker Don Beck helped the Mandela government with social engineering the reconciliation process that was depicted in the movie Invictus. Rugby was considered a white sport in South Africa. Don Beck exploited the common "Purpleness" in the traditional black community and the white Afrikaner sports fans of the Springboks rugby team to unite the nation emotionally around rugby, skillfully using the African miner's song Shosholoza as the team song.


Once again we find ourselves confronting existential problems threatening the planet such as climate change, species extinction, pandemics, and the widening inequality gap. To solve these we desperately need Tier 2 thinking to emerge and take hold.


And, that process has begun.







 
 
 

Comments


Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by JJ Musings. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page